Monnie vs Square Loyalty: which one should you choose?

Both want to bring your customers back. Here is what changes, point by point.

Square Loyalty vs Monnie: the key points

Monnie
  • One tap, no app, no account to create
  • No personal data required
  • Where customers come from, and win-back ads
  • No hardware: the plaque is on us

PriceFree, plaque included

Square Loyalty

  • Mobile number given at the counter
  • Square hardware to buy
  • Points only through a Square payment
  • Loyalty built into the POS

Price$588 per year, hardware extra

Point-by-point comparison

Square LoyaltyMonnie
Win-back ads to in-store customers
Apple or Google Wallet card
Messages to customers
POS integration
Price$588 per year, hardware extraFree, plaque included

Who Square Loyalty is for

  • Businesses already taking payments with Square: POS, online store, invoices
  • Businesses that want points based on spend, with VIP tiers
  • Businesses that want customers, emails and SMS in the same tool as the POS

What Square Loyalty costs in the first year

Square Plus: $49/month × 12, per location$588
Square hardware (Reader $59, Stand $149, Terminal $299)to buy
Marketing SMS after the first 5003¢ per message
Total$588 the first year per location, before hardware and SMS (United States, taxes not specified)

MonnieFree, plaque included

Switching from Square Loyalty to Monnie

  1. 1

    Create your business on Monnie from your Google listing: your Square POS stays in place, with nothing to connect.

  2. 2

    Place the free plaque next to the register and activate it with a tap: your customers earn points without giving their number.

  3. 3

    Square Loyalty points are not transferred: your customers start their Monnie card with their first tap. Monnie counts visits, not amounts.

Frequently asked questions

How much does Square Loyalty cost?

Loyalty is included in Square Plus, at $49 a month per location, or $588 a year in the United States, before Square hardware (Reader at $59) and SMS beyond the first 500, at 3¢ per message. Monnie is free during the launch, with no hardware to buy.

Does Square Loyalty work without a Square POS?

No: points are credited by a payment through Square Point of Sale, Square Online or a Square invoice. The Monnie plaque works without a POS; it counts visits, not purchase amounts.

Does Square Loyalty ask customers for their number?

Yes: customers give their mobile number at the register to sign up and earn points. Monnie asks for no number.

Bring in new customers. And bring them back.

It’s free, with no commitment.

Get started free

Information checked on October 26, 2026. Square Loyalty is a trademark of its owner. Some points come from a former customer’s experience.

Sources

See the alternatives to Square Loyalty →

Other comparisons